The Difference Between airbnb “Private Room” and “Entire Place” Listings

Every airbnb listing is assigned a type: shared room (couch surfing), host-resident “private room” (mini-B&B), and host-absent “entire place” (vacation rental).

  • Host-resident “private room” rentals are generally benign or beneficial.
  • Host-absent “entire place” rentals are where the problems are usually found.

The chart below summarizes the differences.

STRs in Portland

(Click on image to enlarge)

An SF Chronicle study earlier this year highlights the difference between airbnb host-resident “private room” rentals and host-absent “entire place” rentals.

airbnb_sf_chart

 

3 responses

  1. Nah! The comparison is a gross oversimplification. I rent an entire place vacation rental that is generally better value than a hotel room and more persoaalized, does not deplete stock of affordable housing as it is aimed at an entirely different rental market – namely short to medium term vacationer usually with family. No horror stories to date as guests are assessed for risk before agreeing to a rental and are kept in communication with prior to and throughout stay. Plus my neighbors keep a close eye out for any trouble. And whether private room or entire place both are economic-investment decisions. Lifestyle decisions are for hippies. Just apply some common sense to renting to the general public. And normally you can “smell” if something isn’t right.

    • I respectfully disagree. It is true that not every airbnb host-absent “Entire Place” rental will be a problem, but when problems arise they seem to track back to host-absent “Entire Place rentals. Also it sounds like you have neighbors who are accepting, which is not always the case. And having a guests stay in your home while you are present and serve as a host is a very personal decision. Deciding to rent a property short-term rather than long-term because you make more money is purely a business decision.

Comments are closed.